回信段落

回信对应的原文内容

原文涵盖的具体 CT能力

原文对应的 Ennis CT倾向 和能力分类

原文对应的Facione CT 能力分类

1

For one thing, to park overnight is to have a garage in the streets. Now it is illegal for anyone to have a garage in the city streets. Clearly, then, it should be against the law to park overnight in the streets.

意识到错误使用类比

或/和

稻草人谬误 (转换意思或概念)

情感倾向(13)

初级说明(2)

策略与方法(12)

解释

2

Three important streets, Lincoln Avenue, Marquand Avenue, and West Main Street, are very narrow. With cars parked on the streets, there really isn’t room for the heavy traffic that passes over them in the afternoon rush hour. When driving home in the afternoon after work, it takes me thirty-five minutes to make a trip that takes ten minutes during the uncrowded time. If there were no cars parked on the side of these streets, they could handle considerably more traffic.

意识到不相关的论述

情感倾向(6)

初级说明(2)

基本支持(5)

分析

评估

3

Traffic on some streets is also bad in the morning when factory workers are on their way to the 6 a.m. shift, then there would be more room for this traffic.

论述本身无问题

(避免过度怀疑合理论述)

情感倾向(4)

基本支持(4)

评估

4

Furthermore, there can be no doubt that, in general, overnight parking on the streets is undesirable. It is definitely bad and should be opposed.

意识到循环论证错误

和/或

缺乏理由

情感倾向(9)

策略与方法(12)

分析

5

If parking is prohibited from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m., then accidents between parked and moving vehicles will be nearly eliminated during this period in any period as highly desirable. So, we should be in favor of prohibiting parking 2 a.m. to 6 a.m.

意识到错误的推理

(例如:其它可能 解决的办法和其它 可能性的存在)

情感倾向(8)

推论(6)

推论

6

Last month, the Chief of Police, Burgress Jones, ran an experiment which proves that parking should be prohibited from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. On one of our busiest streets, Marquand Avenue, he placed experimental signs for one day. The signs prohibited parking from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. During the four-hour period, there was not one accident on Marquand. Everyone knows, of course, that there have been over four hundred accidents on Marquand during the past year.

意识到样本不足

情感倾向(9)

推论(7)

推论

7

The opponents of my suggestions have said that conditions are safe enough now. These people don’t know what “safe” really means. Conditions are not safe if there’s even the slightest possible chance for an accident. That’s what “safe” means. So, conditions are not safe the way they are now.

意识到语意模糊

和/或

使用主观定义

情感倾向(11)

高级说明(9)

分析

8

Finally, let me point out that the Director of the National Traffic Safety Council, Kenneth O. Taylor, has strongly recommended that overnight street parking be prevented on busy streets in cities the size of Moorburg. The National Association of Police Chiefs has made the same re commendation. Both suggest that prohibiting parking from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. is the best way to prevent overnight parking.

论述本身无问题

(正确评估专家 证言的可信度)

情感倾向(4)

基本支持(4)

解释

评估

9

开篇段落:Overnight parking on all streets in Moorburg should be eliminated. To achieve this goal, parking should be prohibited from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. There are a number of reasons why any intelligent citizen should agree.

结尾段落:I invite those who disagree, as well as those who agree with me, to react to my letter through the editor of this paper. Let’s get this issue out in the open.

全面判断观点正误

总结论点

意识到过度概括错误

意识到使用情感语言 说理的错误

情感倾向 (7,10,13)

推论(7)

策略与方法(12)

说明

推论

自我调整