抑郁评分量表

时长(周)

研究数量

例数 (实验组/ 对照组)

效应 模型

综合 效应值

置信区间/95% CI

P-value

组间异质性

HAMD

1

2

90/88

RE

SMD = −2.20

(−3.13, −1.29)

< 0.00001

I² = 51.6%, P = 0.07

2

7

315/325

RE

SMD = −0.97

(−1.55, −0.39)

0.001

4

14

596/576

RE

SMD = −1.24

(−1.65, −0.83)

< 0.00001

6

10

510/518

RE

SMD = −1.04

(−1.42, −0.66)

< 0.00001

8

6

232/214

RE

SMD = −1.22

(−1.94, −0.50)

0.0009

12

4

127/127

RE

SMD = −2.58

(−3.87, −1.29)

< 0.0001

EPDS

1

1

25/24

RE

SMD = −0.53

(−1.11, 0.04)

0.07

I² = 70.5%, P = 0.005

2

2

113/125

RE

SMD = −0.32

(−0.79, 0.14)

0.17

4

1

45/52

RE

SMD = −0.30

(−0.72, 0.11)

0.15

EPDS

6

3

138/149

RE

SMD = −0.79

(−1.15, −0.43)

< 0.0001

I² = 70.5%, P = 0.005

8

2

78/90

RE

SMD = −1.36

(−1.77, −0.94)

< 0.00001

12

1

25/24

RE

SMD = −0.95

(−1.54, −036)

< 0.002

HAMA

2

3

155/155

RE

SMD = −1.02

(−1.26, −0.78)

< 0.00001

I² = 80.3%, P = 0.0004

4

2

83/73

RE

SMD = −1.95

(−2.35, −1.55)

< 0.00001

6

2

115/115

RE

SMD = −1.68

(−3.23, −0.13)

0.03

8

2

82/82

RE

SMD = −0.94

(−1.65, −0.22)

0.01

12

2

77/67

RE

SMD = −3.04

(−4.78, −1.31)

0.0006