参数

PD组(n = 38)

APS组(n = 35)

Z值

P值

F0

/i/

200.50 (155.25~244.50)

161.00 (142.00~206.00)

2.174

0.030^*

/u/

199.00 (151.00~238.50)

159.50 (138.75~204.25)

2.135

0.033^*

/v/

201.50 (160.00~236.25)

162.50 (132.25~194.50)

2.498

0.012^*

/s/

203.50 (155.25~245.25)

166.00 (140.25~204.50)

2.018

0.044^*

/zh/

203.50 (155.00~244.25)

165.00 (144.75~203.75)

2.050

0.040^*

Jitter

/u/

0.27 (0.17~0.48)

0.37 (0.26~0.48)

−1.973

0.049^*

/v/

0.28 (0.16~0.43)

0.46 (0.31~0.54)

−2.888

0.004^*

/o/

0.29 (0.17~0.46)

0.52 (0.35~0.63)

−3.739

0.000^*

/e/

0.36 (0.23~0.49)

0.53 (0.38~0.67)

−2.446

0.014^*

/s/

0.30 (0.19~0.46)

0.41 (0.31~0.60)

−2.401

0.016^*

/zh/

0.35 (0.22~0.44)

0.44 (0.28~0.60)

−2.240

0.025^*

/er/

0.39 (0.29~0.54)

0.56 (0.34~0.99)

−2.180

0.029^*

Shimmer

/i/

1.34 (1.03~1.89)

2.06 (1.37~3.62)

−2.848

0.004^*

/u/

1.58 (1.10~2.30)

2.38 (1.64~3.78)

−2.894

0.004^*

/v/

1.69 (0.93~2.22)

2.37 (1.68~3.78)

−3.017

0.003^*

/o/

1.86 (1.37~2.66)

3.04 (2.02~4.71)

−3.685

0.000^*

/e/

1.90 (1.36~2.97)

3.05 (1.86~5.29)

−2.939

0.003^*

/s/

1.40 (1.14~2.04)

2.08 (1.45~4.01)

−3.082

0.002^*

/zh/

1.65 (1.14~2.61)

4.65 (2.68~5.83)

−2.478

0.013^*

HNR

/er/

14.00 (9.25~17.00)

10.50 (7.75~15.00)

2.081

0.005^*