Author, year

Study type

Study period

Group

Age (years)

Sex (F/M)

Exposure factors

NOS

RTS

VATS

RTS

VATS

RTS

VATS

Seder,

2022

Retrospective

2015

~

2019

2133

5979

66.62

±

9.1

66.65

±

8.9

911/1222

2598/3377

①⑦⑨

9

Zheng, L.

2022

Retrospective

2020.12

~

2021.5

43

43

57.98

±

10.70

58.26

±

10.28

14/18

29/25

①②⑤⑥⑦⑨⑩

8

Zhang, F.

2022

Retrospective

2020.11

~

2021.11

54

54

60.5

±

3.5

59.5

±

4

23/31

21/33

③⑤⑥⑦⑩

9

Montagne,

2022

Retrospective

2012.1

~

2019.12

234

436

64.49

±

10.49

65.24

±

9.36

147/87

297/139

①⑦

6

Qu,

2022

Retrospective

2020.8

~

2021.4

316

316

58.48

±

0.54

57.93

±

0.62

140/176

123/193

①②⑤⑦⑩

8

Li, R.

2022

Retrospective

2020.9

~

2021.12

292

292

59.25

±

1.83

59

±

2

128/164

124/168

①②③④⑤⑦⑨⑩

9

Jin, 2022

Retrospective

2017.5

~

2020.5

157

163

-

-

-

-

①②③④⑤⑥⑦⑨⑩

8

Jian,

2022

Retrospective

2017.7

~

2021.8

30

32

46.97

±

10.81

50.47

±

12.60

12/18

11/21

①②⑤⑦⑨⑩

8

Chen, D. L.

2022

Retrospective

2016

~

2018

107

144

69.8

±

4.1

69.5

±

3.7

53/54

72/72

①②③⑤⑥⑦⑨⑩

9

Veronesi,

2021

Retrospective

2017.4

~

2018.11

38

39

69

±

8.3

69

±

7.3

21/17

23/16

①④⑤⑦⑨

7

Huang,

2021

Retrospective

2015.1

~

2019.12

335

350

59.89

±

10.78

58.78

±

9.39

148/187

142/208

①③⑤⑦⑨⑩

8

Haruki,

2021

Retrospective

2011.1

~

2020.4

104

286

65.5

±

7.5

63.75

±

8.5

59/45

175 /111

①②⑤

7

Chen, D.

2021

Retrospective

2011.11

~

2018.1

50

80

54.7

±

10.3

57.7

±

9.7

15/35

26/54

①②⑤⑦

7

Zhang, Y.

2020

Retrospective

2015.6

~

2019.8

257

257

53.53

±

10.96

52.21

±

11.89

84/173

89/168

①②④⑤⑨⑩

7

Sesti,

2020

Retrospective

2008

~

2013

409

409

75.5

±

4.33

75.25

±

3.83

176/33

188/221

⑦

6

Lee,

2020

Retrospective

2016

~

2018

118

49

67.5

±

2.25

66.5

±

3

58/60

13/36

①②③④⑤⑦

7

Cui,

2020

Retrospective

2010

~

2014

4537

4537

66.8

±

9.8

66.8

±

9.6

1955/2582

2012/2525

④

6

Bao,

2016

Retrospective

2014.9

~

2015.7

69

69

58.6

±

8.8

59.9

±

9.7

26/43

26/43

②③⑤⑦⑩

8

Mungo,

2016

Retrospective

2007

~

2014

53

80

65.75

±

2.75

67.75

±

2

-

-

③④⑤⑦

6