墩柱模型

工况

CIP桥墩

SPC桥墩

ESP桥墩

预加载

9.515

12.611

13.437

初始

9.599

12.604

13.863

0.068 g

9.538

12.857

13.221

0.137 g

9.037

12.334

12.334

0.196 g

8.809

11.954

13.985

0.274 g

8.448

11.343

11.791

0.391 g

8.821

11.368

12.911

0.431 g

8.009

11.646

12.085

0.55 g

7.954

10.958

10.943

0.65 g

7.472

10.028

11.384

0.783 g

7.271

9.513

10.782

0.9 g

6.896

8.96

10.220

变化率

28.16%

28.91%

26.28%