No. | Algorithm | Best | Mean | SD | Worst | Time(s) | |
F1 | ABC | 2.27e−11 | 2.60e−10 | 1.54e−10 | 6.86e−10 | 0.4462 | |
CABC | 1.78e−17 | 2.06e−16 | 1.34e−16 | 5.34e−16 | 0.4537 | ||
RABC | 1.68e−33 | 1.27e−32 | 1.46e−32 | 7.79e−32 | 0.6073 | ||
CRABC | 1.34e−37 | 6.97e−37 | 4.18e−37 | 6.97e−37 | 0.6310 | ||
F2 | ABC | 6.32e−07 | 1.29e−06 | 3.18e−07 | 1.89e−06 | 0.7552 | |
CABC | 1.31e−09 | 2.65e−09 | 7.27e−10 | 4.04e−09 | 0.7669 | ||
RABC | 1.18e−24 | 6.87e−24 | 9.64e−24 | 4.61e−23 | 1.0908 | ||
CRABC | 1.40e−26 | 1.45e−25 | 3.19e−25 | 1.763e−24 | 1.1240 | ||
F3 | ABC | 9.51e−00 | 1.61e+01 | 3.38e−00 | 2.11e+01 | 0.4845 | |
CABC | 6.90e−00 | 1.14e+01 | 2.28e−00 | 1.51e+01 | 0.4896 | ||
RABC | 1.06e−18 | 2.53e−02 | 1.31e−01 | 7.18e−01 | 0.6808 | ||
CRABC | 4.18e−18 | 7.87e−03 | 4.29e−02 | 2.35e−01 | 0.6981 | ||
F4 | ABC | 4.90e−03 | 1.52e−00 | 1.75e−00 | 7.08e−00 | 0.9228 | |
CABC | 7.73e−04 | 0.77e−00 | 1.63e−00 | 8.58e−00 | 0.9208 | ||
RABC | 3.32e−16 | 2.09e+01 | 1.28e+01 | 2.86e+01 | 1.4459 | ||
CRABC | 9.71e−17 | 1.43e+01 | 1.43e+01 | 2.86e+01 | 1.4454 | ||
F5 | ABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.6308 | |
CABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.6536 | ||
RABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1.0017 | ||
CRABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.9529 | ||
F6 | ABC | 5.16e−02 | 9.66e−02 | 2.06e−02 | 1.39e−01 | 1.1588 | |
CABC | 2.89e−02 | 6.39e−02 | 1.43e−02 | 9.24e−02 | 1.1987 | ||
RABC | 7.91e−06 | 5.33e−05 | 4.49e−05 | 1.70e−04 | 1.6393 | ||
CRABC | 1.33e−06 | 7.49e−05 | 5.89e−05 | 2.32e−04 | 1.6959 | ||
F7 | ABC | −78.33233 | −78.33233 | 8.393e−14 | −78.33233 | 1.1682 | |
CABC | −78.33233 | −78.33233 | 4.25e−14 | −78.33233 | 1.0862 | ||
RABC | −78.33233 | −78.33233 | 1.69e−14 | −78.33233 | 1.4216 | ||
CRABC | −78.33233 | −78.33233 | 1.87e−14 | −78.33233 | 1.7591 | ||
F8 | ABC | 2.12e−10 | 3.31e−02 | 1.81e−01 | 9.95e−01 | 1.0795 | |
CABC | 3.98e−13 | 8.82e−11 | 3.18e−10 | 1.69e−09 | 1.1049 | ||
RABC | 0 | 6.06e−09 | 2.26e−08 | 1.18e−07 | 1.5440 | ||
CRABC | 0 | 1.63e−09 | 8.88e−09 | 4.87e−08 | 1.4962 | ||
F9 | ABC | 1.66e−06 | 4.52e−06 | 1.60e−06 | 7.59e−06 | 1.0678 | |
CABC | 9.39e−09 | 1.76e−08 | 5.96e−09 | 3.95e−08 | 1.0404 | ||
RABC | 8.88e−16 | 1.01e−15 | 6.49e−16 | 4.44e−15 | 1.5265 | ||
CRABC | 8.88e−16 | 8.88e−16 | 0 | 8.88e−16 | 1.5537 | ||
F10 | ABC | 2.87e−11 | 9.09e−09 | 1.46e−08 | 6.24e−08 | 0.9956 | |
CABC | 4.55e−15 | 2.72e−09 | 1.11e−08 | 5.56e−08 | 1.0998 | ||
RABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1.3693 | ||
CRABC | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1.4010 | ||
F11 | ABC | 4.90e−05 | 1.29e−04 | 9.17e−05 | 5.05e−04 | 0.6.473 | |
CABC | 2.64e−06 | 3.31e−05 | 2.51e−05 | 9.50e−05 | 0.6772 | ||
RABC | 1.13e−19 | 1.58e−10 | 7.27e−10 | 3.99e−09 | 0.9935 | ||
CRABC | 3.64e−26 | 4.87e−10 | 1.61e−09 | 8.19e−09 | 0.9954 | ||
F12 | ABC | 2.57e−04 | 4.22e−04 | 9.28e−05 | 6.55e−04 | 37.7078 | |
CABC | 1.56e−06 | 6.01e−06 | 2.40e−06 | 1.15e−05 | 37.9231 | ||
RABC | 0 | 4.68e−11 | 2.02e−10 | 1.06e−09 | 57.2289 | ||
CRABC | 0 | 1.30e−14 | 7.13e−14 | 3.91e−13 | 56.6982 |