|   
  |       (1)  |       (2)  |       (3)  |       (4)  |       (5)  |       (6)  |       (7)  |       (8)  |       (9)  |       (10)  |    
|   VARIABLES  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |       esg  |    
|   did  |       1.161***  |       1.071***  |       1.049***  |       1.060***  |       1.056***  |       1.064***  |       1.063***  |       1.067***  |       1.083***  |       1.036***  |    
|   
  |       (0.280)  |       (0.252)  |       (0.252)  |       (0.252)  |       (0.252)  |       (0.252)  |       (0.251)  |       (0.251)  |       (0.251)  |       (0.250)  |    
|   Size  |       
  |       2.199***  |       2.342***  |       2.357***  |       2.366***  |       2.366***  |       2.360***  |       2.348***  |       2.358***  |       2.282***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       (0.058)  |       (0.064)  |       (0.065)  |       (0.065)  |       (0.064)  |       (0.064)  |       (0.065)  |       (0.065)  |       (0.066)  |    
|   Lev  |       
  |       
  |       −2.087***  |       −2.300***  |       −2.922***  |       −2.922***  |       −2.914***  |       −2.884***  |       −3.346***  |       −3.316***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.380)  |       (0.426)  |       (0.433)  |       (0.432)  |       (0.432)  |       (0.431)  |       (0.433)  |       (0.428)  |    
|   ROA  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       −1.241  |       −3.575***  |       −5.223***  |       −5.215***  |       −5.309***  |       −5.529***  |       −3.995***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (1.078)  |       (1.120)  |       (1.206)  |       (1.206)  |       (1.209)  |       (1.205)  |       (1.199)  |    
|   ATO  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       1.095***  |       1.048***  |       1.051***  |       1.031***  |       1.068***  |       0.935***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.173)  |       (0.173)  |       (0.173)  |       (0.172)  |       (0.171)  |       (0.171)  |    
|   Cashflow  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       3.379***  |       3.355***  |       3.329***  |       3.113***  |       3.366***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.956)  |       (0.956)  |       (0.956)  |       (0.953)  |       (0.947)  |    
|   Indep  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       1.311  |       1.196  |       1.739  |       1.817*  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (1.093)  |       (1.095)  |       (1.098)  |       (1.095)  |    
|   Top1  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       0.570  |       1.034**  |       0.153  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.411)  |       (0.414)  |       (0.425)  |    
|   FirmAge  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       1.692***  |       1.355***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.199)  |       (0.198)  |    
|   SOE  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       1.381***  |    
|   
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       
  |       (0.140)  |    
|   Constant  |       20.457***  |       −30.348***  |       −32.645***  |       −32.831***  |       −33.361***  |       −33.448***  |       −33.806***  |       −33.701***  |       −39.005***  |       −36.666***  |    
|   
  |       (0.076)  |       (1.320)  |       (1.389)  |       (1.396)  |       (1.393)  |       (1.392)  |       (1.438)  |       (1.440)  |       (1.539)  |       (1.566)  |    
|   Observations  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |       9942  |    
|   R-squared  |       0.163  |       0.294  |       0.296  |       0.296  |       0.299  |       0.300  |       0.300  |       0.300  |       0.305  |       0.312  |    
|   industry  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |    
|   year  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |       YES  |    
|   F  |       17.23  |       732.4  |       499.5  |       375.8  |       311.2  |       260.9  |       223.7  |       196  |       186.5  |       183.2  |    
|   Adj R-squared  |       0.156  |       0.288  |       0.290  |       0.290  |       0.293  |       0.294  |       0.294  |       0.294  |       0.299  |       0.306  |