PSO-CK

SPSO

PSO-LDIW

PSO-TVAC

SDPSO

RPSO

MJPSO

F1

Best value

2.76e−03

4.33e−03

1.95e−04

1.29e−03

4.70e−05

1.76e−03

8.71e−08

Mean

3.79e−02

1.42e−02

8.65e−04

7.35e−03

5.81e−04

1.02e−02

8.62e−07

Std. Dev.

3.48e−02

1.01e−02

4.30e−04

5.14e−03

9.58e−04

8.27e−03

9.61e−07

F2

Best value

3.10e−02

8.41e+00

5.88e−02

4.17e−01

1.43e+00

2.77e−01

9.63e−04

Mean

1.62e−01

4.31e+01

2.51e−01

2.52e+02

2.33e+01

5.02e+02

4.48e−03

Std. Dev

1.17e−01

4.05e+01

1.42e−01

1.09e+03

3.00e+01

1.50e+03

2.86e−03

F3

Best value

1.16e−01

3.68e−02

5.23e−03

8.88e−02

6.63e−04

8.60e−02

3.38e−05

Mean

4.70e−01

2.04e−01

1.70e−01

2.63e+00

2.97e−01

1.75e+00

6.68e−03

Std. Dev.

4.54e−01

2.07e+01

1.82e−01

2.69e+00

4.95e−01

1.69e+00

7.39e−03

F4

Best value

2.81e−01

2.44e+00

6.13e−02

2.27e−01

1.21e−01

2.49e−01

1.27e−02

Mean

6.56e−01

1.33e+01

1.76e−01

6.35e−01

2.98e−01

5.38e−01

6.77e−02

Std. Dev.

4.74e−01

1.03e+01

8.04e−02

3.38e−01

1.30e−01

3.61e−01

4.42e−02

F5

Best value

0

4.00e+01

0

0

0

0

0

Mean

2.40e+00

1.29e+03

2.50e−01

1.05e+00

2.30e+00

1.40e+00

1.00e−01

Std. Dev.

1.28e+00

1.70e+03

4.33e−01

8.65e−01

1.52e+00

1.02+00

3.00e−01

F6

Best value

1.87e+00

6.19e+00

1.67e−02

4.29e−02

1.50e−02

6.41e−02

6.31e−04

Mean

4.28e+00

1.25e+00

1.22e+00

1.83e+00

2.43e+00

1.88e+00

3.82e−01

Std. Dev.

1.13e+00

5.14e−01

6.54e−01

7.05e−01

1.04e+00

8.11e−01

5.71e−01

F7

Best value

1.21e−03

6.51e−04

6.99e−05

4.88e−02

1.69e−04

2.37e−01

7.57e−07

Mean

4.02e+00

1.82e+00

1.13e+00

3.69e+00

2.40e+00

4.40e+00

7.00e−02

Std. Dev.

3.32e+00

2.22e+00

1.67e+00

2.75e+00

2.73e+00

5.57e+00

1.87e−01

F8

Best value

4.58e−02

9.41e+00

2.15e−04

4.31e−03

1.26e−05

3.15e−03

1.77e−06

Mean

2.66e+00

3.23e+01

8.46e−03

4.62e−02

6.66e−03

3.36e−02

2.78e−03

Std. Dev.

4.10e+00

2.08e+01

6.31e−03

4.61e−02

7.28e−03

3.55e−02

4.76e−03